EyebrarianPrize winnersGet the app

Books › About that night › Books like it

If you loved

Books like About that night

A tense, fast-paced mystery where romantic guilt collides with a desperate race to clear one's name. These 12 books are the closest matches in mood, pace and themes, with what each one shares with About that night.

  • tense
  • paranoid
  • shadowy
  1. 01

    The night she disappeared

    April Henry

    A tense, guilt-laced mystery that races against the clock to uncover a missing teen's fate.

    Shares:
    • tense
    • urgent
    • anxious
  2. 02

    You will be mine

    Natasha Preston

    A claustrophobic, slasher-style thriller where romantic anticipation curdles into a desperate fight for survival.

    Shares:
    • tense
    • paranoid
    • urgent
  3. 03

    See You Later

    Christopher Pike

    A nostalgic, twisty descent into the dark side of first love and the dangerous allure of second chances.

    Feels:
    • unsettling
    • melancholic
    • suspenseful
  4. 04

    Deadly little secret

    Laurie Faria Stolarz

    A suspenseful, angsty dive into the irresistible pull of a dangerous boy and the chilling reality of being watched.

    Shares:
    • tense
    • shadowy
  5. 05

    The fill-in boyfriend

    Kasie West

    A sweet, trope-driven high school romance where a desperate prom-night lie blossoms into a genuine, swoon-worthy connection.

    Feels:
    • sweet
    • swoony
    • nostalgic
  6. 06

    The case for Jamie

    Brittany Cavallaro

    A tense, atmospheric boarding school mystery wrapped around the aching silence of a fractured friendship.

    Shares:
    • tense
    • shadowy
  7. 07

    Party line

    A. Bates

    A casual teenage social experiment spirals into a tense, high-stakes mystery where unseen voices hide real-world dangers.

    Shares:
    • tense
    • shadowy
    • urgent
  8. 08

    Macarons at midnight

    Suzanne Nelson

    A sugar-dusted, Cinderella-esque tween romance that balances the thrill of a first crush with the warmth of the bakery kitchen.

    Feels:
    • cozy
    • sugar-dusted
    • cheerful
  9. 09

    I Know What You Did Last Summer

    Lois Duncan · 1973

    A claustrophobic descent into paranoia where a single terrible secret slowly unravels the lives of four teenagers.

    Shares:
    • tense
    • paranoid
    • shadowy
    • urgent
  10. 10

    The truth about forever

    Sarah Dessen

    A sun-soaked summer of chaotic catering gigs, found family, and learning to let go of the need to be perfect.

    Feels:
    • sun-drenched
    • bittersweet
    • comforting
  11. 11

    Girl in the White Van

    April Henry

    A claustrophobic, pulse-pounding thriller about survival and the desperate bonds forged in captivity.

    Shares:
    • tense
    • urgent
  12. 12

    Genuine fraud

    E. Lockhart

    A sharp, twisting psychological puzzle about shifting identities and the dangerous gravity of an intense friendship.

    Shares:
    • tense

Back to About that night