EyebrarianPrize winnersGet the app

Books › An Instance of the Fingerpost › Books like it

If you loved

Books like An Instance of the Fingerpost

A labyrinthine, multi-layered puzzle box of a novel where truth is a matter of perspective and everyone is lying. These 12 books are the closest matches in mood, pace and themes, with what each one shares with An Instance of the Fingerpost.

  • shadowy
  • claustrophobic
  • conspiratorial
  • murky
  1. 01

    The Nine Tailors

    Dorothy Leigh Sayers · 1959

    A deeply atmospheric puzzle steeped in the haunting lore of church bells and the damp, isolating chill of the English Fens.

    Shares:
    • erudite
  2. 02

    Death at the president's lodging

    Michael Innes · 1936

    A classic locked-room puzzle steeped in the quiet scandal of an English college.

    Shares:
    • claustrophobic
    • intellectual
  3. 03

    Farriers' Lane

    Anne Perry

    A shadowy London mystery where drawing-room gossip and gritty police work converge to unearth a sinister truth.

    Shares:
    • shadowy
    • claustrophobic
  4. 04

    The Daughter of Time

    Josephine Tey · 1954

    A cozy, fiercely intelligent armchair mystery that turns historical research into a gripping psychological puzzle.

    Feels:
    • cerebral
    • cozy
    • contemplative
  5. 05

    One Corpse too Many

    Ellis Peters · 1979

    A comforting yet suspenseful medieval mystery where worldly wisdom and quiet observation triumph over the chaos of civil war.

    Feels:
    • earthy
    • cloistered
    • suspenseful
  6. 06

    Autumn lace

    Eileen Jackson

    A spirited heroine navigates a sprawling Welsh estate filled with dark secrets, jealous rivalries, and a dangerous, foreboding romance.

    Feels:
    • foreboding
    • tense
    • atmospheric
  7. 07

    The Leper of Saint Giles

    Ellis Peters · 1981

    A methodical, atmospheric medieval mystery where quiet observation and deep compassion unravel the darkest of human secrets.

    Feels:
    • atmospheric
    • cloistered
    • shadowed
  8. 08

    Gaudy night

    Dorothy L. Sayers · 1993

    A fiercely intellectual and deeply romantic slow-burn mystery set within the cloistered, autumnal walls of an Oxford women's college.

    Shares:
    • erudite
  9. 09

    Year of Wonders

    Geraldine Brooks · 2001

    A haunting, beautifully rendered portrait of a community pushed to the brink and a woman forging her own salvation in the crucible of a plague.

    Shares:
    • claustrophobic
  10. 10

    Once upon a river

    Diane Setterfield

    A fog-drenched, folkloric mystery that unfolds like a dark fairy tale told by a roaring fire.

    Feels:
    • fog-drenched
    • atmospheric
    • eerie
  11. 11

    The Daughter of Deceit

    Victoria Holt

    A dramatic, twist-filled historical romance steeped in the theatrical world of the early 1900s, where family secrets and romantic betrayals keep the pages turning.

    Feels:
    • theatrical
    • intriguing
    • emotionally turbulent
  12. 12

    Devil and the Dark Water

    Stuart Turton

    A dread-soaked, locked-room puzzle box set on the high seas, where every shadow hides a demon or a deadly secret.

    Shares:
    • claustrophobic

Back to An Instance of the Fingerpost