Books like Bad Penny

A rugged, slow-burn Western romance about two guarded souls finding a second chance at family under the wide Wyoming sky. These 12 books are the closest matches in mood, pace and themes, with what each one shares with Bad Penny.

rugged
guarded
rustic
sun-baked

01
To claim a wife
Susan Fox
A tense, angst-filled ranch romance where bitter resentment slowly gives way to undeniable yearning and hard-won forgiveness.
Shares:
- rustic
- earnest
- angsty
02
Cowboy Wants A Wife (Hitched)
Susan Fox
A classic clash of city glitz and country grit that melts into a deeply comforting, swoony romance.
Shares:
- earnest
03
The rancher's twin troubles
Laura Altom
A heartwarming, tender romance about healing old wounds and finding unexpected family amidst the chaos of raising twins.
Shares:
- earnest
- hopeful
- second chances
- found family
04
Wyoming Wedding
Barbara McMahon
A classic marriage-of-convenience romance set against the rustic backdrop of a Wyoming ranch, where a grieving widow must learn to trust a rugged cowboy.
Shares:
- guarded
- rustic
- earnest
- hopeful
05
Home on the Ranch
Allison Leigh
A classic, tension-filled ranch romance where forced proximity turns bitter enemies into a passionate, healing family.
Shares:
- rustic
- earnest
06
My Three Girls
Susan Floyd
A tender marriage-of-convenience romance where guarded hearts are melted by the undeniable pull of a ready-made family.
Shares:
- guarded
- earnest
- protective
- hopeful
07
There's Something About a Cowboy
Candace Schuler, Susan Fox and others
A sun-drenched, angsty collection of second chances and rugged romance across sprawling ranches.
Shares:
- sun-baked
- earnest
- angsty
- second chances
08
The Traveling Kind
Janet Dailey · 1981
A rustic, simmering romance about the tension between a grounded life and an untamable heart.
Shares:
- guarded
- rustic
- earnest
09
Heartbreaker
Linda Howard
A rugged, high-stakes battle of wills where fierce independence collides with undeniable, simmering passion.
Shares:
- rugged
- earnest
10
The rancher and the redhead
Rebecca Winters
A classic, sun-baked western romance where familial duty collides with unexpected, heart-softening love.
Shares:
- rustic
- sun-baked
- earnest
- protective
11
Bunking Down With The Boss
Charlene Sands
A sun-drenched, close-proximity ranch romance where simmering suspicion gives way to irresistible, undeniable attraction.
Shares:
- rustic
- earnest
12
Unexpectedly Expecting ! (Lone Star Canyon)
Susan Mallery
A sassy, small-town battle of the sexes that melts into a surprisingly tender story of unexpected family.
Feels:
- cozy
- lighthearted
- romantic

Back to Bad Penny