Books like I Love My New Toy! (Elephant and Piggie)

A hilarious, high-stakes emotional rollercoaster about the fragility of things and the durability of friendship. These 12 books are the closest matches in mood, pace and themes, with what each one shares with I Love My New Toy! (Elephant and Piggie).

energetic
expressive
warm
reassuring

01
I Will Surprise My Friend! (Elephant and Piggie)
Mo Willems
A hilarious, high-energy exploration of what happens when the anticipation of a surprise spirals completely out of control.
Shares:
- energetic
- warm
- playful
- earnest
02
Pigs Make Me Sneeze! (An Elephant and Piggie Book)
Mo Willems
A hilarious, high-drama exploration of friendship anxiety wrapped in a fast-paced, dialogue-driven comedy.
Shares:
- warm
- playful
- melodramatic
- earnest
03
Train!
Judi Abbot
A cheerful, energetic ride through the bumpy but rewarding landscape of learning to play together.
Shares:
- playful
- earnest
04
Love Is My Favorite Thing
Emma Chichester Clark
A warm, energetic picture book that captures the chaotic joy of a dog whose heart is just a little too big.
Shares:
- energetic
- warm
- playful
- earnest
05
George and Martha
James Marshall
A masterclass in deadpan humor and the gentle, forgiving art of true companionship.
Shares:
- playful
- forgiveness
06
Poppleton in Winter
HOUGHTON MIFFLIN HARCOURT
A cozy, snow-dusted celebration of friendship and the quiet joys of the winter season.
Shares:
- warm
- earnest
- humorous
07
Llama Llama Mad at Mama
Anna Dewdney
A rhythmic, empathetic journey through the overwhelming storm of big toddler feelings and the comforting anchor of a parent's love.
Shares:
- warm
- playful
08
A Weekend With Wendell
Kevin Henkes
A gentle, deeply relatable exploration of childhood boundaries and the quiet triumph of finally standing up for yourself.
Shares:
- warm
- playful
- humorous
09
Little blue and little yellow
Leo Lionni · 1959
A minimalist masterpiece that captures the transformative magic of friendship through the simplest of shapes and colors.
Shares:
- warm
- playful
- earnest
10
If you give a pig a party
Laura Numeroff
A delightfully exhausting chain reaction of fun that proves how one tiny idea can snowball into an entire afternoon of joyful chaos.
Shares:
- energetic
- warm
- playful
- humorous
11
Harold and the Purple Crayon
Crockett Johnson · 1981
A quiet, magical stroll through the limitless landscape of a child's imagination, drawn one line at a time.
Shares:
- earnest
12
Mr. Wuffles!
David Wiesner
A cinematic, wordless adventure that shrinks the reader down to navigate the perilous, everyday terrain of a house cat's domain.
Shares:
- playful

Back to I Love My New Toy! (Elephant and Piggie)