EyebrarianPrize winnersGet the app

Books › Loving That O'Connor Boy › Books like it

If you loved

Books like Loving That O'Connor Boy

A nostalgic, angsty dive into the classic good-girl-meets-misunderstood-bad-boy dynamic, fueled by high school gossip and parental disapproval. These 12 books are the closest matches in mood, pace and themes, with what each one shares with Loving That O'Connor Boy.

  • angsty
  • nostalgic
  • swoony
  • gossip-fueled
  1. 01

    Prom Date

    Diane Hoh · 1996

    A quintessential 90s teen slasher where taffeta and tiaras are soaked in paranoia and high school social politics turn deadly.

    Feels:
    • paranoid
    • tense
    • retro-slasher
  2. 02

    Good-Bye, Pretty One (Wildfire)

    Lucille S Warner

    A sun-drenched summer of first jobs, new crushes, and the bittersweet journey of growing up.

    Shares:
    • nostalgic
    • earnest
  3. 03

    Little sister

    Yvonne Greene

    An earnest high school romance steeped in the sting of sibling rivalry and the struggle to step out of a beautiful older sister's shadow.

    Shares:
    • angsty
    • earnest
    • dramatic
    • first love
  4. 04

    The boy-oh-boy next door

    Rita Miami · 1993

    A nostalgic dive into the dizzying highs and mortifying lows of a neighborhood first crush.

    Shares:
    • nostalgic
    • earnest
    • dramatic
  5. 05

    Dance With Me

    Winifred Madison

    A sun-drenched summer of tangled affections, cousin rivalry, and the struggle to stay true to your roots.

    Shares:
    • angsty
    • nostalgic
    • earnest
    • dramatic
  6. 06

    The popularity plan

    Rosemary Vernon

    A sweet, earnest exploration of high school social dynamics, where the thrill of newfound attention clashes with the quiet yearning for a genuine connection.

    Shares:
    • nostalgic
    • earnest
    • sympathetic
  7. 07

    The Popularity Summer

    Rosemary Vernon

    A sun-drenched exploration of teenage loyalty, shifting social dynamics, and the sweet trials of summer romance.

    Shares:
    • nostalgic
    • earnest
    • first love
  8. 08

    Just You and Me (Wildfire)

    Ann Martin

    A classic high school romance where academic ambition collides with the messy reality of love triangles and fading relationships.

    Shares:
    • angsty
    • nostalgic
    • earnest
  9. 09

    Deadly Attraction (Point)

    Diane Hoh · 1993

    A quintessential 90s teen thriller where a casual summer fling curdles into a suffocating nightmare of obsession and revenge.

    Shares:
    • nostalgic
  10. 10

    The fill-in boyfriend

    Kasie West

    A sweet, trope-driven high school romance where a desperate prom-night lie blossoms into a genuine, swoon-worthy connection.

    Shares:
    • nostalgic
    • swoony
    • earnest
  11. 11

    My Darling, My Hamburger

    Paul Zindel · 1969

    A tender and angsty exploration of first love, awkwardness, and the fragile bonds of teenage friendship.

    Shares:
    • angsty
    • nostalgic
    • earnest
    • sympathetic
  12. 12

    Pants on Fire

    Meg Cabot

    A sun-drenched, chaotic summer romp about the exhausting work of keeping up appearances and the relief of finally letting go.

    Feels:
    • summery
    • chaotic
    • romantic

Back to Loving That O'Connor Boy