EyebrarianPrize winnersGet the app

Books › Magic for Liars › Books like it

If you loved

Books like Magic for Liars

A gritty, emotionally bruised noir where the real mystery is how to survive the resentment of being the ordinary sister in a magical world. These 12 books are the closest matches in mood, pace and themes, with what each one shares with Magic for Liars.

  • shadowed
  • bittersweet
  • atmospheric
  • angsty
  1. 01

    The Echo Wife

    Sarah Gailey

    A chilling, razor-sharp exploration of identity and betrayal wrapped in a claustrophobic, speculative nightmare.

    Shares:
    • cynical
  2. 02

    What Lies in the Woods

    Kate Alice Marshall

    A dark, tangled exploration of childhood secrets and the devastating cost of keeping them buried.

    Shares:
    • cynical
  3. 03

    The Ten Thousand Doors of January

    Alix E. Harrow

    A lush, defiant love letter to the magic of storytelling and the hidden thresholds that lead us to where we belong.

    Shares:
    • atmospheric
  4. 04

    Down among the sticks and bones

    Seanan McGuire

    A dark, lyrical fairy tale about the monstrous expectations placed on little girls and the terrifying, beautiful worlds they escape to.

    Shares:
    • melancholic
  5. 05

    Just Like Home

    Sarah Gailey

    A claustrophobic, dread-soaked exploration of the terrifying, unconditional love between a daughter and her monster.

    Feels:
    • claustrophobic
    • dread-soaked
    • visceral
  6. 06

    One Of Us Is Lying

    Karen M. McManus

    A twisty, high-stakes puzzle box where high school stereotypes shatter under the pressure of a murder investigation.

    Feels:
    • paranoid
    • tense
    • claustrophobic
  7. 07

    A DEADLY GAME OF MAGIC

    Joan Lowery Nixon · 1983

    A delightfully eerie, locked-room thriller where every shadow hides a trick and survival depends on seeing through the illusion.

    Feels:
    • claustrophobic
    • eerie
    • tense
  8. 08

    Malice

    Heather Walter

    A lush, sapphic villain origin story that asks what happens when the monster decides she would rather burn the kingdom down than lose the girl.

    Shares:
    • cynical
  9. 09

    Silver is for secrets

    Laurie Faria Stolarz

    A sun-drenched summer getaway slowly rots into a paranoid nightmare of psychic visions and hidden betrayals.

    Feels:
    • dread-soaked
    • tense
    • eerie
  10. 10

    The Invisible Library

    Genevieve Cogman

    A witty, gaslamp-lit heist across alternate realities where books are the ultimate currency and magic bleeds into the cobblestones.

    Shares:
    • wry
  11. 11

    Listen for the Lie

    Amy Tintera

    A razor-sharp, darkly hilarious thriller that skewers small-town gossip and true-crime obsession through the eyes of a gloriously unreliable narrator.

    Shares:
    • cynical
    • wry
  12. 12

    Witchmark

    C. L. Polk

    A gaslit blend of murder mystery, political intrigue, and tender romance set in the shadow of a magical world war.

    Shares:
    • atmospheric

Back to Magic for Liars