Books like Supernaturally (Paranormalcy #2)

A tense, supernatural journey where a reluctant hero is pulled back into a shadowy world of dark prophecies and shifting identities. These 12 books are the closest matches in mood, pace and themes, with what each one shares with Supernaturally (Paranormalcy #2).

ominous
shadowy
tense
mystical

01
Paranormalcy (Paranormalcy #1)
Kiersten White
A bubbly, snark-filled romp through a supernatural bureaucracy with a heroine who wields a pink taser and a fierce desire for a normal life.
Feels:
- quirky
- upbeat
- playful
02
Evermore
Alyson Noël · 2009
A moody, grief-tinged paranormal romance where overwhelming psychic noise is silenced only by the intoxicating pull of a mysterious stranger.
Feels:
- brooding
- mysterious
- grief-tinged
03
The Awakening
Kelley Armstrong
A breathless, supernatural road trip where survival means trusting the very monsters you were taught to fear.
Shares:
- shadowy
- tense
- urgent
04
Dark Flame
Alyson Noël
A desperate plunge into dark magic where every attempt to save a supernatural romance only deepens the danger.
Shares:
- tense
05
Chosen at Nightfall
C. C. Hunter
A high-stakes supernatural showdown where embracing one's ultimate power is the only path to survival.
Shares:
- tense
- urgent
06
Pure
Jennifer L. Armentrout
An addictive, high-voltage rush of forbidden romance and mythological destiny.
Shares:
- tense
07
Tithe
Holly Black
A grungy, intoxicating plunge into a hidden world where magic is sharp, dangerous, and smells like rust and stale beer.
Feels:
- grungy
- dangerous
- intoxicating
08
Whispers at Moonrise
C. C. Hunter
A dramatic, otherworldly coming-of-age journey wrapped in romantic tension and supernatural mystery.
Shares:
- tense
- suspenseful
09
Fallen
Lauren Kate
A shadowy, gothic slow-burn of destined love and ancient secrets hidden behind the gates of a gloomy reform school.
Shares:
- shadowy
10
Sweet evil
Wendy Higgins
A tenderhearted empath is drawn into an alluring, dangerous world of fallen angels and forbidden romance.
Shares:
- tense
11
Crescendo
Becca Fitzpatrick
A shadowy, angst-fueled dive into supernatural secrets and the turbulent highs and lows of a dangerous romance.
Shares:
- shadowy
- tense
- suspenseful
12
Unearthly (Unearthly #1)
Cynthia Hand
A swoony, atmospheric dive into angelic destiny and the agonizing thrill of a classic paranormal love triangle.
Shares:
- coming-of-age

Back to Supernaturally (Paranormalcy #2)