If you loved

Books like The Mistake

A deliciously satisfying sports romance where the arrogant playboy has to pull out all the stops to win back the girl who outgrew him. These 12 books are the closest matches in mood, pace and themes, with what each one shares with The Mistake.

energetic
steamy
triumphant
lighthearted

01
The Score
Elle Kennedy
A high-heat, banter-filled college romance that lures you in with a carefree fling before delivering a surprisingly profound emotional gut-punch.
Shares:
- energetic
- steamy
- playful
- swoony
02
The Goal
Elle Kennedy
A steamy, tender sports romance about a fiercely independent woman learning to let a steadfast partner share the load.
Shares:
- steamy
- playful
- swoony
- earnest
03
Icebreaker
Hannah Grace
A high-energy, banter-filled collision of fierce ambition and golden-retriever warmth that melts into a remarkably healthy, high-spice romance.
Shares:
- playful
- swoony
- earnest
- banter-heavy
04
The One That Got Away
Kelly Hunter
A steamy, second-chance contemporary romance where comfortable stability collides with blistering, unresolved chemistry.
Shares:
- steamy
- playful
05
Fiancee By Mistake
Kate Walker
A snowbound, high-angst clash of wills where mistaken identity fuels a fiery, irresistible attraction.
Shares:
- earnest
06
Misconduct
Penelope Douglas
A high-stakes, tension-soaked collision of forbidden desire and closely guarded secrets.
Shares:
- steamy
07
Pucking Around
Emily Rath
A wildly indulgent, high-heat hockey romance that trades unnecessary angst for fierce devotion, endless banter, and a cozy polyamorous dynamic.
Shares:
- steamy
- playful
- swoony
- banter-heavy
08
Chasing Red
Isabelle Ronin
An addictive, high-stakes college romance that pairs a fiercely guarded heroine with a wealthy, determined athlete who will do anything to break down her walls.
Shares:
- swoony
- earnest
09
Wildfire
Hannah Grace
A sun-drenched, high-heat summer romance that balances sizzling forbidden tension with tender emotional healing.
Shares:
- playful
- swoony
- earnest
10
True Love and Other Disasters
Rachel Gibson
A fiery, opposites-attract sports romance that trades on sharp banter and scorching chemistry.
Shares:
- energetic
- steamy
- playful
- swoony
11
Flawless
Elsie Silver
A sun-drenched, banter-filled ride through small-town rodeo country where forced proximity sparks undeniable heat.
Shares:
- playful
- swoony
- earnest
- banter-heavy
12
Last Real Man
Rebecca Flanders
A steamy, high-voltage exploration of a divorced couple who simply cannot stay away from each other.
Shares:
- steamy

Back to The Mistake