EyebrarianPrize winnersGet the app

Books › The night she disappeared › Books like it

If you loved

Books like The night she disappeared

A tense, guilt-laced mystery that races against the clock to uncover a missing teen's fate. These 12 books are the closest matches in mood, pace and themes, with what each one shares with The night she disappeared.

  • tense
  • apprehensive
  • mysterious
  1. 01

    Girl in the White Van

    April Henry

    A claustrophobic, pulse-pounding thriller about survival and the desperate bonds forged in captivity.

    Shares:
    • tense
    • urgent
    • suspenseful
  2. 02

    The girl who was supposed to die

    April Henry

    A breathless, frantic sprint through the dark as you try to outrun killers you don't remember.

    Shares:
    • tense
    • urgent
    • suspenseful
  3. 03

    About that night

    Norah McClintock

    A tense, fast-paced mystery where romantic guilt collides with a desperate race to clear one's name.

    Shares:
    • tense
    • urgent
    • anxious
  4. 04

    Stolen children

    Peg Kehret

    A ticking-clock thriller that trades on quick wits and the fierce, protective instinct of a young protagonist backed into a corner.

    Shares:
    • tense
    • urgent
    • suspenseful
  5. 05

    When Did You See Her Last?

    Lemony Snicket

    A delightfully gloomy, deadpan noir that invites you to wander through a fading town where every answer only leads to more bewildering questions.

    Feels:
    • foggy
    • noir-tinged
    • quirky
  6. 06

    Lost and Found

    Anne E. Schraff · 2002

    A tense, fast-paced urban drama where creeping paranoia gives way to a desperate race to save a fractured family.

    Shares:
    • tense
    • urgent
    • suspenseful
    • anxious
  7. 07

    Local Woman Missing

    Mary Kubica

    A claustrophobic, twist-laden descent into the dark secrets lurking behind manicured suburban lawns.

    Shares:
    • tense
    • urgent
    • suspenseful
  8. 08

    1-800-Where-R-You

    Meg Cabot

    A sharp-tongued, reluctant psychic navigates small-town danger and uneasy alliances in a fast-paced thriller laced with teenage angst.

    Shares:
    • tense
    • urgent
    • suspenseful
  9. 09

    Wish you were dead

    Todd Strasser

    A tense, voyeuristic thriller where anonymous digital gossip bleeds into terrifying real-world consequences.

    Shares:
    • tense
    • urgent
    • suspenseful
  10. 10

    They Never Came Home

    Lois Duncan · 1969

    A tense, vintage mystery that explores the unsettling realization that our siblings might be harboring dangerous secrets.

    Shares:
    • tense
    • urgent
    • suspenseful
    • anxious
  11. 11

    Monday's Not Coming

    Tiffany D. Jackson

    A frantic, heartbreaking descent into the terrifying reality of who society chooses to look for and who it allows to disappear.

    Shares:
    • tense
    • urgent
  12. 12

    Curious case of the ransom riddler

    Kyla Steinkraus

    A ticking-clock puzzle-hunt filled with quirky clues, teamwork, and the distinct smell of rotten eggs.

    Shares:
    • urgent

Back to The night she disappeared