Books like The One That Got Away

A swoony, fast-paced collection of historical romances that proves true love always deserves a second act. These 12 books are the closest matches in mood, pace and themes, with what each one shares with The One That Got Away.

swoony
yearning
heartwarming
cozy

01
Duchess in Love
Eloisa James · 2002
A glittering Regency romp where an estranged husband must woo his own scandalously independent wife.
Shares:
- swoony
- romantic
- witty
02
Yesterday Once More
Debbie Macomber · 1986
A tender, nostalgic journey of returning to the one who got away and finding the courage to stay this time.
Shares:
- romantic
- hopeful
- nostalgic
- enduring love
03
The Strength of Desire
Alison Fraser
A high-stakes, emotionally charged romance where long-buried family secrets and forbidden desires finally boil over.
Shares:
- second chances
04
Her Wish-List Bridegroom
Liz Fielding
A breezy, comforting hometown romance that balances playful banter with the sweet nostalgia of a childhood crush.
Shares:
- cozy
- hopeful
- nostalgic
- second chances
05
Long-lost bride
Day Leclaire
A glittering masquerade ball sets the stage for a dramatic, angst-laced second chance at a once-in-a-lifetime love.
Shares:
- swoony
- romantic
- nostalgic
- second chances
06
Only His
Ann Maxwell · 1991
A sweeping frontier romance where a perilous journey through the Rockies sparks an undeniable, feverish destiny between opposites.
Feels:
- rugged
- sweeping
- intense
07
Enamored (Best Of The Best)
Diana Palmer · 1994
A tense, emotionally charged journey of two estranged lovers navigating the bitter wreckage of their past to find forgiveness.
Shares:
- romantic
- hopeful
- nostalgic
- second chances
08
The Society Catch
Louise Allen
A delightful, fast-paced Regency romp where the exhausting pursuit of perfection is gleefully abandoned for the thrill of misbehavior and a cross-country chase.
Shares:
- cozy
- romantic
09
Just One Kiss
Samantha James
A classic, sweeping historical romance where reluctant vows and simmering tension lead to the slow thaw of a brooding heart.
Shares:
- romantic
10
Tempted By His Kiss
Tracy Anne Warren
A cozy snowbound encounter melts into a scandalous high-society charade in this swoony historical romance.
Shares:
- swoony
- cozy
- romantic
11
Rhys's Redemption
Anne McAllister
A tender, trope-tastic journey of breaking down walls and turning a comfortable friendship into a passionate, lifelong family.
Shares:
- yearning
- hopeful
12
Runaway Fiancee
Sally Wentworth
A high-drama, emotionally charged confrontation between estranged lovers with a year's worth of pent-up resentment and passion.
Shares:
- yearning
- romantic
- second chances
- rekindled passion

Back to The One That Got Away