EyebrarianPrize winnersGet the app

Books › The Sherlockian › Books like it

If you loved

Books like The Sherlockian

A bookish mystery that plunges a quiet literary scholar into a deadly, real-world hunt for a legendary author's missing secrets. These 12 books are the closest matches in mood, pace and themes, with what each one shares with The Sherlockian.

  • intriguing
  • scholarly
  • shadowy
  1. 01

    Moriarty

    Anthony Horowitz

    A fog-drenched descent into a masterfully deceptive Victorian underworld where nothing is as it seems.

    Shares:
    • shadowy
    • suspenseful
  2. 02

    The Stranger Diaries

    Elly Griffiths

    A chilling modern gothic mystery where the safety of a private diary is breached by a killer.

    Shares:
    • suspenseful
  3. 03

    The Valley of Fear

    Arthur Conan Doyle · 2005

    A classic locked-room puzzle that unexpectedly cracks open to reveal a gritty, blood-soaked history of American organized crime.

    Shares:
    • shadowy
  4. 04

    The Suspicions of Mr. Whicher

    Kate Summerscale

    A grim, historical deep-dive into a shocking Victorian murder and the tragic toll it took on the man who tried to solve it.

    Shares:
    • investigative
    • suspenseful
  5. 05

    The Seven-Per-Cent Solution

    Nicholas Meyer

    A clever, gaslit adventure that peels back the myth of a legendary detective to reveal the vulnerable, brilliant human underneath.

    Shares:
    • suspenseful
  6. 06

    A study in Charlotte

    Brittany Cavallaro

    A sharp, moody boarding school mystery wrapped in witty banter and the heavy burden of legacy.

    Feels:
    • moody
    • autumnal
    • tense
  7. 07

    Stalking Jack the Ripper

    Kerri Maniscalco

    A fog-drenched, blood-spattered romp through Victorian London that balances gruesome forensic science with swoony romantic banter.

    Feels:
    • gaslit
    • fog-drenched
    • gruesome
  8. 08

    The Strange Case of the Alchemist's Daughter

    Theodora Goss

    A witty, gaslamp-lit romp where the daughters of literature's most infamous mad scientists team up to reclaim their own stories.

    Feels:
    • gaslamp-lit
    • cozy-macabre
    • sisterly
  9. 09

    Irène

    Pierre Lemaître

    A dread-soaked, high-stakes thriller where a detective's blissful life is shattered by a killer staging savage literary homages.

    Feels:
    • dread-soaked
    • tense
    • macabre
  10. 10

    The Art of Theft

    Sherry Thomas

    A glittering, high-stakes Victorian heist where clever women and their loyal allies infiltrate a festive chateau to steal back dangerous secrets.

    Shares:
    • suspenseful
  11. 11

    The Silkworm

    J. K. Rowling

    A deliciously dark and methodical descent into the petty, cutthroat, and occasionally gruesome underbelly of the London literary scene.

    Feels:
    • chilly
    • atmospheric
    • macabre
  12. 12

    Silent in the sanctuary

    Deanna Raybourn

    A deliciously intriguing historical mystery where aristocratic flirtation collides with snowbound murder in an ancient abbey.

    Shares:
    • intriguing
    • suspenseful

Back to The Sherlockian