Books like The Would-Be Witch

A gentle, nostalgic chapter book that captures the cozy thrill of suspecting there is magic hiding right down the street. These 12 books are the closest matches in mood, pace and themes, with what each one shares with The Would-Be Witch.

cozy
nostalgic
gently mysterious

01
The witch who was afraid of witches
Alice Low · 1978
A gentle, empowering tale of a timid underdog discovering her own unique magic to stand up to her overbearing siblings.
Shares:
- cozy
- gentle
02
Dorrie and the Blue Witch
Coombs
A delightfully cozy, vintage brew of gentle scares and clever triumphs.
Shares:
- nostalgic
- earnest
- gentle
- everyday magic
03
Dorrie and the witch's imp
Patricia Coombs
A charmingly spooky children's tale where magical mischief proves that being perfectly behaved is highly suspicious.
Feels:
- whimsical
- cozy-spooky
- charming
04
The Bone Witch
Rin Chupeco
A lush, darkly enchanting tale of necromancy and ritual that unfolds like a slow, deliberate dance.
Shares:
- earnest
05
Old Black Witch!
Wende Devlin · 1963
A delightfully mischievous, pancake-scented romp that turns a haunted house into a cozy home.
Shares:
- cozy
- nostalgic
- gentle
06
Karen's witch
Ann M. Martin
A delightfully dramatic romp through the neighborhood where everyday oddities are spun into thrilling, safe mysteries by a wildly imaginative narrator.
Shares:
- cozy
- nostalgic
- earnest
- neighborhood mysteries
07
Witch Week
Diana Wynne Jones
A sharply observed, darkly funny boarding school mystery where the magic is just as chaotic and terrifying as the social dynamics of middle school.
Feels:
- paranoiac
- claustrophobic
- darkly whimsical
08
Meg and Mog
Helen Nicoll
A delightfully bold and gently spooky romp where everyday routines meet magical, chaotic mishaps.
Shares:
- nostalgic
- matter-of-fact
09
The Thickety
J. A. White
An atmospheric journey into a forbidden forest where an outcast child uncovers the wondrous truth behind a dark legacy.
Shares:
- earnest
10
Initiation
Lisa J. Smith
A brooding, autumnal plunge into the intoxicating dangers of high school covens and forbidden romance.
Shares:
- earnest
11
The Near Witch
Victoria Schwab
A haunting, wind-swept mystery where childhood folklore bleeds into a chilling reality.
Feels:
- wind-swept
- haunting
- mysterious
12
The Black Witch
Laurie Forest
A tense, atmospheric journey through a treacherous magical university where an unmagical girl must unlearn her prejudices to survive.
Shares:
- earnest

Back to The Would-Be Witch