EyebrarianPrize winnersGet the app

Books › When I was the greatest › Books like it

If you loved

Books like When I was the greatest

A gritty, grounded exploration of sibling loyalty and the sudden, sharp turn of a neighborhood night gone wrong. These 12 books are the closest matches in mood, pace and themes, with what each one shares with When I was the greatest.

  • neighborhood-centric
  • tense
  • loyal
  • protective
  1. 01

    All American Boys

    Jason Reynolds

    A gripping, dual-perspective reckoning with systemic injustice that demands you interrogate your own silence.

    Shares:
    • tense
    • earnest
  2. 02

    The boy in the black suit

    Jason Reynolds

    A tender, grounded exploration of a heavy heart learning how to beat again in the rhythm of a bustling Brooklyn neighborhood.

    Shares:
    • earnest
    • grounded
  3. 03

    If I Grow Up

    Todd Strasser

    A gritty, unflinching look at the impossible choices forced upon a boy trying to survive systemic poverty and neighborhood violence.

    Shares:
    • tense
    • gritty
  4. 04

    The Vanderbeekers of 141st Street

    Karina Yan Glaser

    A bustling, heartwarming story of sibling solidarity and the urgent quest to save a beloved family home.

    Shares:
    • earnest
  5. 05

    The Crossover

    Kwame Alexander

    A kinetic, rhythmic exploration of brotherhood, basketball, and the sudden, sharp pains of growing up.

    Shares:
    • earnest
  6. 06

    Another Brooklyn

    Jacqueline Woodson

    A haunting, poetic plunge into the intoxicating magic of girlhood friendships and the heavy shadows that eventually fracture them.

    Feels:
    • nostalgic
    • bittersweet
    • atmospheric
  7. 07

    The Contender

    Robert Lipsyte · 1967

    A gritty, sweat-soaked coming-of-age classic about finding the strength to stand up when the world tries to keep you down.

    Shares:
    • tense
    • earnest
    • gritty
    • grounded
  8. 08

    The stars beneath our feet

    David Barclay Moore

    A poignant and grounded journey of a young boy navigating the heavy currents of grief and the tense realities of his neighborhood.

    Shares:
    • tense
    • earnest
    • grounded
  9. 09

    The Watsons go to Birmingham--1963

    HOLT MCDOUGAL

    A hilarious, warm-hearted family road trip that unexpectedly collides with a sobering, world-altering moment in American history.

    Shares:
    • tense
    • earnest
  10. 10

    Slam!

    Walter Dean Myers

    A rhythmic, grounded coming-of-age story that hits with the fast-paced energy of a streetball game and the heavy reality of growing up.

    Shares:
    • tense
    • earnest
    • gritty
    • grounded
  11. 11

    The Poet X

    Elizabeth Acevedo

    A fierce, rhythmic heartbeat of a book about a girl learning to carve out her own space in a world that wants her to shrink.

    Shares:
    • tense
    • earnest
  12. 12

    A hero ain't nothin' but a sandwich

    Alice Childress

    A raw, polyphonic chorus of voices orbiting a young boy's struggle with addiction, offering no easy answers but profound empathy.

    Shares:
    • tense
    • gritty

Back to When I was the greatest