Books › What was she thinking?

What was she thinking?
258 pages
A deliciously toxic and claustrophobic descent into the mind of a fiercely observant, dangerously lonely woman.
What it feels like
Reading this novel feels like being cornered at a party by a brilliantly articulate, deeply judgmental stranger whose gossip is too juicy to walk away from, even as you realize she is completely unhinged. The narrative moves at a brisk, inevitable clip, driven by a voice that is simultaneously hilarious, pathetic, and chillingly predatory. You are trapped inside a claustrophobic, dread-soaked atmosphere where every sharp observation masks a profound, festering loneliness. The prose is elegant and venomous, wrapping toxic obsession in the guise of protective friendship. It is a masterclass in the unreliable narrator, delighting readers who crave dark psychological tension, caustic wit, and the slow-motion car crash of self-delusion unraveling on the page.
- Mood
- claustrophobic
- unsettling
- darkly comic
- tense
- Tone
- caustic
- obsessive
- wry
- unreliable
- snobbish
- Pace
- brisk
- Themes
- toxic friendship · loneliness and isolation · self-delusion · destructive obsession · class anxiety
- The writing
- The sentences are sharp, articulate, and dripping with venomous wit and self-justifying elegance.
- The arc
- The journey shifts from a state of cynical, detached observation into a suffocating spiral of obsessive control and chilling revelation.
- Who it's for
- Readers who devour dark psychological character studies and delight in the company of fiercely intelligent, deeply unreliable narrators.
Content notes
- teacher-student sexual relationship
- statutory rape
- emotional abuse
- stalking and obsession
- grooming
About the book
When her new friend and co-worker, Sheba Hart, begins a passionate affair with a male student, schoolteacher Barbara Covett decides to defend Sheba and unknowingly reveals secrets they both hide.
Description from Open Library.
Books like What was she thinking?
See why they match
Romancing The TeacherMarie FerrarellaA warm, secret-laced romance where guarded hearts and hidden identities collide over community service.
Conversations With FriendsSally RooneyA sharp, hyper-observant dive into the messy, overlapping boundaries of friendship, lust, and intellectual posturing.
Foreign AffairsBorisch, Sarah AllanA witty and poignant comedy of manners about lonely academics finding dizzying, unexpected romance while abroad in London.
Pages for YouSylvia BrownriggAn intoxicating, deeply literary exploration of the all-consuming nature of a first queer love.
CracksSheila KohlerA feverish, sun-drenched descent into the intoxicating and cruel world of adolescent obsession.
The AfterglowRose BurghleyA crisp, alpine romantic drama full of unrequited sighs, sophisticated rivals, and frustratingly dictatorial doctors.