Books like Keeping You a Secret

A tender, high-stakes exploration of the terrifying thrill of first queer love and the courage it takes to live out loud. These 12 books are the closest matches in mood, pace and themes, with what each one shares with Keeping You a Secret.

tender
tense
emotionally charged

01
Everything Leads to You
Nina LaCour
A sun-drenched, cinematic love letter to the magic of movie-making and the tender vulnerability of first love.
Shares:
- tender
- earnest
- hopeful
02
If I Was Your Girl
Meredith Russo
A tender, anxiety-laced, and ultimately triumphant exploration of the terrifying leap required to let yourself be truly seen.
Shares:
- tender
- earnest
- vulnerable
- hopeful
03
Pages for You
Sylvia Brownrigg
An intoxicating, deeply literary exploration of the all-consuming nature of a first queer love.
Shares:
- earnest
- sexual awakening
04
It's Not Like It's a Secret
Misa Sugiura
A tender, tangled exploration of first love, family fractures, and the courage it takes to stop hiding.
Shares:
- tender
- earnest
- vulnerable
05
Annie on My Mind
Nancy Garden
A tender, fiercely sincere exploration of first love that feels like a quiet rebellion against a judgmental world.
Shares:
- tender
- earnest
- hopeful
06
Luna
Julie Anne Peters
A poignant, secretive exploration of sibling bonds and the tense, beautiful journey of a transgender teen preparing to show her true self to the world.
Shares:
- tender
- tense
- earnest
- hopeful
07
If You Could Be Mine
Sara Farizan
A desperate, heart-wrenching exploration of how far a person will go to keep the one they love when the world forbids it.
Shares:
- tender
- earnest
08
Almost Perfect
Brian Katcher
A messy, emotionally turbulent exploration of teenage heartbreak, prejudice, and the rocky road to genuine understanding.
Shares:
- tense
- earnest
- vulnerable
- angsty
09
Hush, hush
Becca Fitzpatrick · 2010
A moody, rain-slicked descent into forbidden romance where the love interest is as dangerous as the monsters lurking in the shadows.
Shares:
- angsty
10
Secrets
Kate William · 1983
A deliciously soapy plunge into 1980s high school royalty, where lip gloss and vicious gossip are the ultimate weapons.
Shares:
- tense
- earnest
11
Her Royal Highness
Rachel Hawkins
A cozy, banter-filled sapphic fairy tale set against the misty backdrop of an elite Scottish boarding school.
Feels:
- cozy
- escapist
- misty
12
Tell Me Again How a Crush Should Feel
Sara Farizan
A warm, witty exploration of the sheer panic and ultimate joy of a high school queer awakening.
Shares:
- earnest
- hopeful

Back to Keeping You a Secret