Books like Mistress by Mistake

A delightfully scandalous romp where a case of mistaken identity in the bedchamber leads to an unexpected awakening of the heart. These 12 books are the closest matches in mood, pace and themes, with what each one shares with Mistress by Mistake.

steamy
intimate
scandalous

01
Mistaken Mistress
Margaret McPhee
A classic Cinderella tale wrapped in Regency scandal, where a downtrodden heroine finds her worth in the arms of a notorious rake.
Shares:
- romantic
02
The Master's Mistress
Carole Mortimer
A classic, breathless tale of an innocent swept off her feet by an unapologetic alpha in a cozy, book-filled setting.
Shares:
- intimate
03
Accidental Mistress
Cathy Williams
A dizzying plunge into jet-set glamour that transforms into a surprisingly tender story of a playboy tamed by unexpected fatherhood.
Shares:
- romantic
04
The Earl's Fancy
Charlotte Hines
A delightfully witty romp where a resigned older sister accidentally wins the heart of a teasing earl through sheer exasperation and undignified scrapes.
Shares:
- playful
- hidden desires
05
A Hasty Marriage
Rachelle Edwards
A delightful, old-school romp where a scandalous misunderstanding paves the way for an unexpectedly tender romance.
Shares:
- romantic
- hidden desires
06
Make-Believe Mistress
Katherine Garbera
A steamy, fast-paced fantasy where hidden desires are dragged into the light by a demanding, irresistible force.
Shares:
- steamy
- sensual
- playful
07
Mistress Deception
Susan Napier · 2000
A high-stakes battle of wills where revenge and undeniable attraction collide in a storm of vintage romance angst.
Shares:
- steamy
08
Our Wicked Mistake
Emma Wildes
A shadowy, suspense-laced historical romance where bitter enmity slowly melts into fiery passion under the pressure of a deadly mystery.
Shares:
- witty
- sensual
09
The viscount in her bedroom
Gayle Callen
A tender, slow-burn historical romance about finding passion and healing in the quiet corners of a secluded estate.
Shares:
- intimate
- romantic
10
The Accidental Mistress
Tracy Anne Warren
A delightful Regency romp of disguises, witty banter, and a rakish lord meeting his match in a spirited runaway.
Shares:
- witty
- sensual
- playful
- romantic
11
The Seduction of an Unknown Lady
Samantha James
A moonlit historical romance where dangerous secrets meet fierce, protective passion.
Shares:
- romantic
12
Married By Mistake!
Renee Roszel
A breezy, trope-tastic romp where the chaotic pretense of a fake marriage slowly melts into genuine, swoon-worthy romance.
Shares:
- playful
- romantic

Back to Mistress by Mistake