EyebrarianPrize winnersGet the app

Books › My Sister the Vampire #1 › Books like it

If you loved

Books like My Sister the Vampire #1

A delightfully spooky twist on the classic twin-swap trope, blending glitter, goth, and heartwarming sisterhood. These 12 books are the closest matches in mood, pace and themes, with what each one shares with My Sister the Vampire #1.

  • playful
  • cozy-spooky
  • cheerful
  1. 01

    Dangerous girls

    R.L. Stine

    A breathless, nostalgic descent into teen angst and bloodlust, fueled by dark secrets and sibling loyalty.

    Feels:
    • shadowy
    • tense
    • creeping dread
  2. 02

    Daughters of Darkness

    L. J. Smith

    A deliciously dramatic plunge into small-town secrets, dangerous boys, and the intoxicating pull of the supernatural.

    Shares:
    • earnest
  3. 03

    The Replacement

    Brenna Yovanoff

    A grunge-tinged, rust-scented descent into a macabre underworld where monsters and humans bleed together.

    Feels:
    • macabre
    • dread-soaked
    • claustrophobic
  4. 04

    Eighth grade bites

    Heather Brewer

    A delightfully angsty blend of supernatural suspense and the everyday horrors of middle school.

    Shares:
    • earnest
  5. 05

    The lost twin

    Sophie Cleverly

    A shadowy boarding school mystery where a quiet girl must step into her missing sister's shoes to uncover a trail of hidden secrets.

    Shares:
    • earnest
  6. 06

    Vampire Kisses

    Ellen Schreiber

    A delightfully campy, early-2000s goth-girl fantasy where small-town boredom collides with spooky, swoon-worthy romance.

    Shares:
    • playful
    • earnest
  7. 07

    Wildwood Dancing

    Juliet Marillier

    A lush, wintry fairy tale that weaves the fierce bonds of sisterhood with the intoxicating, dangerous allure of a hidden magical realm.

    Shares:
    • earnest
  8. 08

    Fake blood

    Whitney Gardner

    A hilarious, big-hearted romp through the supernatural awkwardness of middle school crushes and trying way too hard to be cool.

    Shares:
    • playful
    • cozy-spooky
    • lighthearted
    • humorous
  9. 09

    Bad Girls Don't Die

    Katie Alender · 2009

    A snarky, fast-paced descent into suburban horror where high school angst collides with genuine supernatural dread.

    Feels:
    • creepy
    • tense
    • chilling
  10. 10

    Secret vampire

    Lisa Smith

    A deliciously angsty paranormal romance where the ultimate choice is between a tragic mortal end and a dark, forbidden eternity.

    Shares:
    • earnest
  11. 11

    The Fury and Dark Reunion

    L. J. Smith

    A deliciously angsty, gothic plunge into small-town secrets and a deadly, centuries-old supernatural love triangle.

    Shares:
    • earnest
  12. 12

    Evernight

    Claudia Gray

    A moody, atmospheric dive into forbidden romance and hidden identities set against the backdrop of a chillingly perfect boarding school.

    Shares:
    • earnest

Back to My Sister the Vampire #1