EyebrarianPrize winnersGet the app

Books › The Borden Murders › Books like it

If you loved

Books like The Borden Murders

An immersive, documentary-style exploration of a notorious historical mystery that invites readers to weigh the evidence themselves. These 12 books are the closest matches in mood, pace and themes, with what each one shares with The Borden Murders.

  • suspenseful
  • inquisitive
  • atmospheric
  • chilling
  1. 01

    What Were the Salem Witch Trials

    Joan Holub

    A brisk, accessible journey into one of history's most fascinating and chilling moments of mass panic.

    Shares:
    • objective
    • curious
  2. 02

    Maplecroft

    Cherie Priest

    A dread-soaked historical fantasy where a notorious accused murderer turns her infamous weapon against the malevolent horrors rising from the sea.

    Shares:
    • atmospheric
  3. 03

    The Suspicions of Mr. Whicher

    Kate Summerscale

    A grim, historical deep-dive into a shocking Victorian murder and the tragic toll it took on the man who tried to solve it.

    Shares:
    • suspenseful
    • investigative
    • analytical
  4. 04

    A Good Girl's Guide to Murder

    Holly Jackson

    A true-crime podcast brought to life as a high-stakes, mixed-media puzzle box that dares you to stop reading.

    Shares:
    • suspenseful
    • inquisitive
  5. 05

    Stalking Jack the Ripper

    Kerri Maniscalco

    A fog-drenched, blood-spattered romp through Victorian London that balances gruesome forensic science with swoony romantic banter.

    Feels:
    • gaslit
    • fog-drenched
    • gruesome
  6. 06

    The Science of Sherlock Holmes

    E. J. Wagner

    A gaslit journey through the Victorian era's transition from superstition to the cold, hard facts of forensic science.

    Shares:
    • analytical
    • curious
  7. 07

    A Northern Light

    Jennifer Donnelly

    A beautifully written, atmospheric coming-of-age tale where a young woman's love of words becomes her only escape from a life of rural hardship.

    Shares:
    • atmospheric
  8. 08

    Murder in Greenwich

    Mark Fuhrman

    A chilling true crime investigation into how wealth and privilege can stall justice for decades.

    Shares:
    • chilling
    • investigative
    • objective
  9. 09

    The fact of a body

    Alex Marzano-Lesnevich

    A heavy, introspective descent into the murky waters of justice, trauma, and the unsettling collision of personal history with violent crime.

    Feels:
    • heavy
    • unsettling
    • dread-soaked
  10. 10

    Assassination vacation

    Sarah Vowell

    A delightfully morbid and deeply nerdy road trip through the weirdest, darkest corners of American history.

    Feels:
    • quirky
    • macabre
    • reflective
  11. 11

    The Pact

    Jodi Picoult

    A heart-wrenching exploration of how little we truly know about the people we love the most.

    Feels:
    • heartbreaking
    • tense
    • claustrophobic
  12. 12

    A study in Charlotte

    Brittany Cavallaro

    A sharp, moody boarding school mystery wrapped in witty banter and the heavy burden of legacy.

    Shares:
    • atmospheric

Back to The Borden Murders