EyebrarianPrize winnersGet the app

Books › The Suspicions of Mr. Whicher › Books like it

If you loved

Books like The Suspicions of Mr. Whicher

A grim, historical deep-dive into a shocking Victorian murder and the tragic toll it took on the man who tried to solve it. These 12 books are the closest matches in mood, pace and themes, with what each one shares with The Suspicions of Mr. Whicher.

  • grim
  • suspenseful
  • tragic
  • obsessive
  1. 01

    The Science of Sherlock Holmes

    E. J. Wagner

    A gaslit journey through the Victorian era's transition from superstition to the cold, hard facts of forensic science.

    Shares:
    • analytical
    • historical
  2. 02

    Dust and Shadow

    Lyndsay Faye · 2009

    A fog-drenched, meticulously crafted Victorian procedural that pits cold logic against visceral, real-world horror.

    Shares:
    • grim
    • analytical
  3. 03

    Silent in the sanctuary

    Deanna Raybourn

    A deliciously intriguing historical mystery where aristocratic flirtation collides with snowbound murder in an ancient abbey.

    Shares:
    • suspenseful
    • family secrets
  4. 04

    Portrait of a Killer

    Cornwell, Patricia Daniels · 2002

    A dark, obsessive deep-dive into Victorian London that applies modern forensic science to history's most infamous cold case.

    Shares:
    • grim
    • obsessive
    • analytical
  5. 05

    The fact of a body

    Alex Marzano-Lesnevich

    A heavy, introspective descent into the murky waters of justice, trauma, and the unsettling collision of personal history with violent crime.

    Feels:
    • heavy
    • unsettling
    • dread-soaked
  6. 06

    The Saltmarsh Murders

    Gladys Mitchell

    A delightfully eccentric Golden Age mystery that spikes the traditional cozy village formula with Freudian psychology and macabre wit.

    Feels:
    • cozy-but-weird
    • slightly macabre
    • atmospheric
  7. 07

    The Devil in the White City

    Erik Larson · 2003

    A mesmerizing descent into the Gilded Age where the pinnacle of human achievement casts the darkest of shadows.

    Shares:
    • suspenseful
  8. 08

    A perilous undertaking

    Deanna Raybourn

    A fiercely witty romp through Victorian London, fueled by crackling banter, deadly secrets, and a heroine who absolutely refuses to behave.

    Feels:
    • gaslit
    • adventurous
    • crackling
  9. 09

    The Borden Murders

    Sarah Miller

    An immersive, documentary-style exploration of a notorious historical mystery that invites readers to weigh the evidence themselves.

    Shares:
    • suspenseful
    • analytical
    • investigative
  10. 10

    The Sherlockian

    Graham Moore

    A bookish mystery that plunges a quiet literary scholar into a deadly, real-world hunt for a legendary author's missing secrets.

    Shares:
    • suspenseful
    • investigative
  11. 11

    The angel of darkness

    Caleb Carr · 1997

    A gaslit descent into the darkest corners of Gilded Age New York, where early psychology battles a terrifyingly elusive evil.

    Shares:
    • suspenseful
  12. 12

    The Feather Thief

    Kirk Wallace Johnson

    A bizarre and gripping descent into an underground world where the obsession with beauty drives people to commit unthinkable crimes.

    Shares:
    • suspenseful
    • obsessive

Back to The Suspicions of Mr. Whicher